Balancing Coherence and Complexity

If you want to create better designs with people’s preference in mind, my Botanic Bootcamp The Preference Matrix for Naturalistic Design offers a deep dive into the four key factors coherence, complexity, legibility, and mystery and how they shape our emotional connection to landscapes.

With over 20 practical strategies, you’ll learn to how to better design spaces that are ecologically sustainable, visually engaging, and intuitive to navigate.

Crafting incredible plant combinations is something that every horticulturist desires.  We want our plantings to be engaging and beautiful. But, with so many plants, many gardeners wonder where to start?

We can frame our plant combinations in the mindset of balancing coherence and complexity from Rachel and Stephen Kaplan’s Preference Matrix.  Having both factors in plant pairings can create dynamic combinations that humans prefer when looking at landscapes.

From research, the Kaplans noticed that participants had certain preferences when looking at images of landscapes.  And, when they considered the similar patterns between those images they developed a matrix to explain those preferences.  The matrix has four components based on the combinations of the immediate or inferred human desire to understand and explore.

  • Coherence is where humans group things together in our visual field (immediate understanding).

  • Complexity is the perception of richness in a scene. Our eyes move around with different stimuli (immediate exploration).

  • Legibility is the ability to read the landscape and recognize how to traverse the space (inferred understanding).

  • Mystery is where information about the scene is hidden from us and the promise of more exists (inferred exploration).

BALANCING COHERENCE AND COMPLEXITY

When we are thinking about creating powerful plant combinations, coherence and complexity from this model can be great allies.  In garden design we often refer to coherence as repetition, harmony, and rhythm, and complexity is thought of as complementary colors, contrasts, or different shapes or forms.  

Many of my favorite combinations that I have seen over the years exploring the wild and gardens has been a balance between coherence and complexity, where the mind is able to group plants together based on color, texture, or form, and yet there’s a contrasting element to spice things up.  

Let's look at some real-world examples that demonstrate these principles in action. Each shows different ways to achieve coherence while maintaining engaging complexity. You can use these images to practice thinking about coherence and complexity below.

  • Before you read the caption pause and ask what makes the plants an effective combination.

  • Don’t worry too much on the specific plants and whether you can grow them or if they are native or not. Think how can you use the elements in your own design.

  • Also, remember landscape preferences are based on averages. I can’t promise you’ll love every image below, but I guarantee you’ll find inspiration by looking at them.

Hellstrip in Nacogdoches, TX. Coherence: warm colors. Complexity: flower shape.

Lurie Garden, IL. Coherence: the gray color in Eryngium (rattlesnake master) and the buildings behind. Complexity: different shapes from round flowers to flat structures behind.

Great Dixter, United Kingdom. Coherence: repeating white and maroon/pink colors. Complexity: the different textures and forms.

Great Dixter, United Kingdom. Coherence: repeating colors of yellow and purple. Complexity: having different plant texture and forms.

 

Chanticleer, PA. Coherence: repeating green. Complexity: Contrasting textures.

 

Chanticleer, PA. Coherence: repeating greens and blondes. Complexity: different plant shapes and architectures.

Rotterdam, Netherlands. Coherence: flower shape and cool color scheme. Complexity: different plant habits.

Oudolf Field, United Kingdom. Coherence: the purple color in all three plants. Complexity: different plant forms and floral architecture.

Oudolf Field, United Kingdom. Coherence: repeating the purple color. Complexity: solid flower spikes and wispy grass texture.

Montrose, NC. Coherence: repeating purple. Complexity: color in flowers and foliage for different textures.

Chanticleer, PA. Coherence: cool color scheme. Complexity: different flower shapes and plant architecture.

Hillside, United Kingdom. Coherence: repeating yellow and warm colors and repetition of the spikes. Complexity: the different plant forms and flower architectures.

PRACTICE CREATING COMBINATIONS

If you’re looking to make better plant combinations, thinking of how to balance coherence and complexity is a great place to start. Here are a few strategies you can use.

  1. Observe plants in the wild. You may notice combinations around you that are really captivating. Mirror them in your garden.

  2. Consider scale. Across a large site, coherence might be more important to help the plantings feel unified, but closer up there may be opportunities to play off more contrast.

  3. An easy framework. As you saw above a quick way to have an engaging combination is repeat a color in 2 or 3 plants and then vary the form, texture, or architecture. Just remember that on some plants, color may not last long, and you need that complexity to keep it engaging.

  4. Keep things simple. Too many different plants can quickly become quite chaotic. Don’t overdo it with too many plants.

  5. Screenshot ideas on your phone. I find myself capturing images that I see online. I file them into albums for ideas later and review them when making plant choices or buying seed and plants for the year.

  6. Test combinations at the small scale. Plants in pots are movable and offer you the chance to move things around before fully committing in the garden. You can find fun pairings this way.

  7. Create floral arrangements. Arrangements offer the chance to see what two plants would look like in close proximity. If nothing else, float flowers and leaves in a bowl of water or gather clippings and lay them out on the ground. Bringing plants together sparks ideas.

  8. Get comfortable with experimenting and failure. I planted Oenothera lindheimeri ‘Sparkle White’ (gaura) and Penstemon laxiflorus (nodding penstemon) together and thought they would work. It looked like the garden vomited pink cotton candy. It was too much. I removed the gaura so that the penstemon could really shine.

  9. Borrow ideas. I can’t tell you the number of horticulturists I’ve heard say they love to steal ideas from others. Read books, visit gardens, and study the work of others.

As you train your eye, you’ll start noticing coherence and complexity more in the wild and in gardens. Your garden is ultimately a reflection of your creativity and vision. Let coherence and complexity (and legibility and mystery) be tools in your design toolkit that help you create plantings that are both visually harmonious and full of discovery.

After all, the best gardens don't just follow principles. They tell stories. The question is what story will your garden tell?


KEEP GROWING

Phoradendron leucarpum | American mistletoe

“What in the tarnation,” I muttered under my breath. Walking in the backyard picking up fallen sticks I noticed in the distance a branch that was quite different. Instead of a drab detritus, there was life in its verdant green.

 

Phoradendron leucarpum

 

It was mistletoe, and the strong winds had blown it down and far out of the drip line of the giant water oak in our backyard.

What timing! A week before the holidays and here mistletoe had fallen in our backyard.  I delighted seeing it laden with white berries and tried to recall if I had ever seen fruit on a specimen.

Thomas Nuttall named the genus Phoradendron. This name translates as thief (phor-) wood (-dendron), an appropriate allusion to their parasitic habit that robs the tree of water, nutrients, and sugars. The particular one in my water oak is the native Phoradendron leucarpum (American mistletoe). And, leucarpum translates as white fruit, a nod to the sparkling berries.

 

The white berries of mistletoe

 

The common name refers to its dispersal mechanism. Mistle is an Old English word for dung, and tan, which became -toe, means twig. Though dung might seem repulsive, in olden days people were amazed to see a plant spread by bird poop that had no roots. They revered a plant that could grow out of another tree and be emerald green in the depths of winter.

And over the years it has been known as an emblem of peace, for protecting homes and babies from evil spirits, and as a symbol for resurrection. I chuckle when people talk about kissing others under the mistletoe for the holidays. Nothing says I love you like smooching underneath a parasite that is spread by bird droppings.  Well, a hemiparasite that is.  Mistletoe is able to both photosynthesize its sugars as well as rob from the plant to which it is attached.

It can get to the point where it is too abundant on branches and starts leaching the tree’s life away.  Growing up I don’t recall a plethora of mistletoe in Tennessee.  But, after moving to Raleigh, NC it seemed like it was everywhere.  I even saw a thornless Gleditsia triacanthos (honey locust) once that was so loaded with mistletoe the plant looked chlorotic.

The leftmost Gleditsia triacanthos is so loaded with mistletoe that it is showing signs of nitrogen deficiency.

But, my water oak only has a few sprigs of mistletoe that are nice visual diversity amongst the tree’s bare silhouette in the winter time. The spheres of green hide amongst the fog of foliage during the growing season, but once frost burns the leaves off, their bushy silhouettes are seen against the sky. And, the birds that I’ve watched dancing in the winter trees the past few weeks also enjoy the fruit and help to spread it. American mistletoe is also the only host plant for the Great Purple Hairstreak, a beautiful butterfly which I first saw at Ephemera Farm in October of 2022.

 

A tattered Great Purple Hairstreak finds respite on my finger. This beautiful butterfly relies on our native American mistletoe as a host plant.

 

We humans can enjoy mistletoe, too. Harvesting mistletoe can be tricky. I mainly rely on what blows out of trees.  Some places it grows low enough to collect, but others shoot the sprigs out of trees with shotguns and rifles.

I realize that this species is not one that we might use typically in horticulture, but some people grow and propagate it for use around the holidays. The RHS provides details on how to grow your own.  Just know that the host plants for our native American mistletoe maybe a bit different. With having a plant that’s broken off and laden with berries, I’m looking to find a few good trees on the fencerow to use as a host and have more plants (and hopefully hairstreaks) in about five years. It can grow on 60 different species of trees including ashes, elms, maples, oaks, poplars, tupelos, walnuts, and willows. The inside of the fruit is sticky and viscus, too, hence the family’s name Viscaceae. Thus, some people just stick the berries on tree bark.

That way I won’t have to rely on wind for mistletoe in future years to hang in the house and entice my sweetie for a kiss.

Just don’t mention the parasitic bird poop part to Karen.


KEEP GROWING

Layer by Layer: Simplifying Naturalistic Planting Design

NEED HELP WITH YOUR NATURALISTIC PLANTING?

My 2+ hour Botanic Bootcamp session The Naturalistic Planting Primer covers reading your site, crafting the flora, how to group plants into layers​, creating the design with design principles, site preparations, planting, post-planting management, and more!


Planting design can be overwhelming for people. Where do you start? How do you combine plants together?

With naturalistic planting, grouping plants in layers simplifies design. Layers help you think about how plants fill space—not just horizontally, but also vertically. Planting in layers also resembles what we see in wild, healthy ecosystems.

LAYERS IN THE WILD

If you look across a wildscape, you will notice layers of vegetation where there are clear breaks between certain plant types. It may be one, two, three, or more that are visible.

The theory of niche partitioning explains why these layers exist. A niche is the role that an organism has in the environment while considering the resources that an organism uses to survive and its interactions with other creatures. No two organisms can occupy the same niche. For example, low sedges grow along the ground in filtered light while tall perennials soar above.

In plant communities, we see plants have evolved different growth habits to survive in the same space. In Sowing Beauty, James Hitchmough notes two driving factors of why plants grow in layers are their different strategies of light capture and for enhancing the potential for pollination.

The layer of seasonal flowers Castilleja indivisa (Texas Indian paintbrush) and Salvia lyrata (lyre-leaf sage) emerge out of a grassy layer while Baptisia alba (white wild indigo) rises in prominence behind, forming a third layer in this roadside community.  

In this bog habitat, Sarracenia alata (pale pitcher plant) grows out of a grassy matrix. Scattered around are woody shrubs beneath a canopy of pines.

Even in this managed pasture, two layers are visible, the grassy groundcover and the emerging Baptisia sphaerocarpa (yellow wild indigo).

THE PLAYERS IN LAYERS

Layers simplify our design approach by allowing us to break the planting into smaller groups.

We need a system to utilize layers in naturalistic planting design. Different practitioners have approached their use of layers similarly but have given them different names. If we look at three different books, Planting: A New Perspective by Piet Oudolf and Noel Kingsbury, Planting in a Post-wild World by Thomas Rainer and Claudia West, and Naturalistic Planting Design by Nigel Dunnett, we can see a model for four distinct layers in naturalistic planting design. They include

  • primary plants / structural layer / anchors

  • repeating plants / seasonal theme / satellites

  • scatter plants / filler plants / free floaters

  • matrix

The top three in the list above primarily function for beauty and ecology while the matrix serves as a groundcover layer to prevent weed growth.

 

This table provides an overview of the different names of each naturalistic layer from various authors. 

 

PRIMARY PLANTS / STRUCTURAL LAYER / ANCHORS

This layer provides the dominant presence and aesthetics for most of the growing season in the planting. The plants can be shrubs or small trees, but in naturalistic design big perennials typically fill this role.

The species in this layer are competitors that can achieve size over the growing season and have a presence for several months. Another important aspect is they carry winter interest for the slower part of the gardening season.

Examples include Baptisia alba (wild white indigo), Eutrochium fistulosum (joe pye weed), Eryngium yuccifolium (rattlesnake master), Rudbeckia maxima (giant coneflower), and Panicum virgatum (switchgrass).

Baptisia alba (right) is a wonderful early structural plant at Ephemera Farm.  After it finishes flowering, it produces structural seedheads that can last in the garden into winter.  On the left is Arnoglossum plantagineum (prairie indian plantain), and while it provides good structure in the spring, it will go dormant in early summer as the stem collapses.  

At Chanticleer, Eryngium yuccifolium (rattlesnake master) acts as a structural plant in this planting on the elevated walkway.  It starts flowering in the summer, and the seedheads last into winter.  

SCATTER PLANTS / SEASONAL THEME / SATELLITES

This layer provides our seasonal interest in the planting. The strategy here is to choose 2 or 3 plants that pair well together in different seasons for around 4–6 waves of color to appear throughout the growing season. These waves are when plants come into bloom at similar times to provide color interest.

Here again I like to think of plants that can provide multi-season interest. For example, Pycnanthemum tenuifolium (narrow-leaf mountain mint) is a lower growing species, but by using it we can have interesting columns of foliage in the spring, flowers in the summer, and seedheads for autumn and winter.

I do like the name satellites, this idea of plants revolving around greater beings of mass in the garden that are anchors. Nigel Dunnett notes that he sites these around the anchors and then has them scattered throughout the planting as singles and groups of three. Others approach this layer considering sociability, a plant’s natural approach to arranging themselves in groups in the wild. There may be groups of 3–20 plants based on what naturally occurs in the wild.

Here’s a list of species I’ve used as season interest here at Ephemera Farm.

  • March: Narcissus pseudonarcissus (lent lily), Muscari neglectum (grape hyacinth), Ipheion uniflorum (star flower)

  • April May: Penstemon digitalis (foxglove beardtongue), Phlox pilosa (prairie phlox), Marshallia caespitosa (clumping Barbara’s buttons)

  • June-July: Pycnanthemum tenuifolium (narrow-leaf mountain mint), Stokesia laevis (Stokes’s aster)

  • August–September: Gaillardia aestvalis var. winkleri ‘Grape Sensation’ (Winkler’s firewheel), Physostegia virginiana (obedient plant)

  • October–November: Muhlenbergia capillaris (pink muhly grass), Symphyotrichum oblonigfolium (aromatic aster), Symphyotrichum lanceolatum (panicled aster)

At Ephemera Farm Phlox pilosa and Penstemon species make a wonderful seasonal filler layer.  

Verbena bonariensis (tall verbena) and Oenothera lindheimeri (white gaura) make a good seasonal theme layer in this planting in the Tower of London Superbloom.  

SELF SOWERS / FILLER PLANTS / FREE FLOATERS

This layer features ruderals that self sow themselves around the garden. These plants don’t last long, and they maybe quite abundant after planting and less years later. But, if bare soil or a disturbance occurs, they will quickly germinate and fill in the gap. You are basically creating your own seed bank in the soil, but instead of it dominantly being weeds it is now attractive plants.

We generally have two periods here at Ephemera Farm where seeds germinate, fall and winter for most cool-season plants and short-lived perennials and spring for most warm season plants.

  • Fall: Strepthanthus maculatus (clasping jewelflower), Lupinus subcarnosus (sandyland bluebonnet), Trifolium incarnatum (crimson clover), Gaillardia pulchella (firewheel), Nemophila phacelioides (Texas baby blue eyes)

  • Spring: Gomphrena globosa (globe amaranth), Celosia spicata (celosia), Chamaecrista fasciculata and Chamaecrista nictitans (partridge peas), Cosmos sulphureus (sulfur cosmos)

Lupinus subcarnosus (sandy-land bluebonnet) germinates to fill gaps in my plantings at Ephemera Farm.  

Nemophila phacelioides (Texas baby blue eyes) germinates in the fall in disturbed spots and then rewards us with beautiful flowers in early spring.  

THE MATRIX

I’m happy that the authors all chose the same name for the groundcover layer. But, I think that’s because of how this layer is primarily functional in nature. The role is to cover the ground to prevent the growth and emergence of weeds.

Carex texensis (Texas sedge), Carex flaccosperma (blue wood sedge), Carex cherokeensis (Cherokee sedge), Sporobolus heterolepis (prairie dropseed) and Eragrostis spectabilis (purple love grass) are a few that I use in this role. However, forbs like Glandularia canadensis (rose vervain) and Conoclinium greggii (Gregg’s mist flower) that spread as groundcovers can also function in this role.

Bulb foliage from Narcissus (daffodil) or Lycoris (red spider lily) can also serve this function, shifting from seasonal filler to ground cover layer later.

Carex texensis (Texas sedge) has become my go to matrix species at Ephemera Farm. It’s native on site and is tolerant of sun and shade conditions.

Echinacea pallida ‘Hula Dancer’ (pale coneflower) and Dianthus carthusianorum (Carthusian pink) emerge from the matrix of Sporobolus heterolepis in Oudolf Field.

PUTTING LAYERS INTO PRACTICE

If you’re starting from scratch, here’s the steps I would take to start developing layered naturalistic plantings.

  • You first have to know what species will perform well in your area. Visiting arboretea, wild areas, trial gardens, and garden centers is a good start. Many of the plants I now use in my beds were trialed on site for a few years before committing to their use.

  • Keep a bloom calendar of when plants emerge and go through stages of growth and flowering. Note in your calendar what does well in your area and as well as others in your general proximity. From here you can start to build the timing between plant foliage, flower, fruit, or form.

  • Once you have a species list, grab pictures you’ve taken or found on the internet and build a mood board. It can easily be done in a word document or slide show app. Consider if there are ways that you can play off the layers colors or textures. For example, when my Joe pye weed blooms, it’s a similar color to the Gaillardia ‘Grape Sensation’ flowers.

 

An example mood board of the species I rely upon for color at Ephemera Farm. Grouping plants in such a visual pattern allows you to start seeing patterns and combinations possible.

 
  • Make sure that plants are compatible with their survival strategy. Competitors can outcompete lower layers.

  • Consider height. Is everything the same height or is there variation? You are trying to avoid having everything the exact same height; otherwise you will just have one layer. Use references to determine the height. It helps to sketch out the plant height. Or, put the heights into Excel and make a bar graph. Even if you aren’t very good at drawing, just drawing height bars will help you compare how tall they get.

  • Start simple. For small areas, limiting species diversity is important for greater impact. Too many species in one area will look like a mess. Assuming you have 3 structural plants, 5 waves of 3 seasonal plants (3 × 5 =15), and 2 matrix options, that’s 20 (3 + 15 +2) different plants.

  • Choose your anchor plants first. Winter interest is one of the most important considerations in design because there will be a few months of the year when these plants are the dominant interest in the garden. And, make sure they can persist even with ice and snow load. While we are mainly focused on perennials, don’t forget that woody trees and shrubs can serve as anchors. Some woody species also can be coppiced to limit their eventual size.

  • I would argue the next step is to decide on what you want your groundcover layer to be. Some practitioners will cover the site with the groundcover species first to allow it to establish for a few years. This manages the weed growth, and the stress will keep vigorous plants in check. Matrix species generally look better in bulk instead of having one here, one there. It’s helpful to grade between their blocks to slowly shift from say Carex texensis to Carex flaccosperma so they look blended.

  • Next, fill in with the seasonal theme layer. Consider spacing them in so they appear in groups of 3 to 10 with some sole outliers.

  • Last, plant or seed in the filler plants so they can fill gaps while the seasonal theme layer is getting established.

After planting evaluation is key. What looks good and what works? You may have to do slight adjustments over the years. But, that’s part of the joy of gardening with layers in naturalistic planting is learning what works together to create a beautiful, ecologically friendly design.


KEEP GROWING